How to Play Your Employer Retirement Plan Card Right

Written by:

Ann Garcia, CFP®

Head of Content & Author

Tihomir Yankov, JD

Financial Advisor, Founder & CEO

Retirement isn't an end—it's a beginning for something new. A beginning of 30+ years filled with travel, hobbies, volunteering, or whatever it is you want to dedicate your time, mind, and energy to. But here’s the challenge: how do you save enough to cover your expenses for what could very well end up being half of your adult life?

Saving enough to live 30 or 40 years without income can feel overwhelming. But with the right approach, it’s absolutely doable.

How Employer Retirement Plans Work

Employer plans are a type of investment account that is offered by your employer that also gives you certain tax benefits—either now or in the future. This setup allows your employer to withhold a part of your paycheck and redirect it straight into your retirement plan without it ever hitting your bank account. The most common types of employer plans are 401(k)s and SIMPLE IRAs for those who work in the private sector and 403(b) and 457 plans for people working in the public or nonprofit sector.

Employer retirement plans with automated investment features offer convenience but come with risks. While they simplify saving, they also have the potential to lock in errors, making it harder to reverse their effects if not caught early.

Employer retirement plans have basically replaced company pensions, leaving it to employees to ensure that they’re saving and investing for their own retirement. As a result, you alone are responsible for:

Choosing your investments;
Ensuring you’re contributing the right amount so you can retire when you want to; and
Pulling the right levers to maximize the account’s monumental impact on your taxes—both today and in retirement!

About 60% of Americans have access to an employer plan at work. And if you don’t, then you need to play the Individual Retirement Account (IRA) card instead.

So, let’s break it down into actionable steps that will get the most out of your employer retirement savings plan.

Step 1: Put Time to Work (Non-Negotiable!)

If you want to know the biggest and most common financial regret—look no further! Because the biggest factor in wealth creation—and retirement savings in particular—is the number of years you allow your investments to grow.

If you gave your investments 30 years of growth at an average rate of 10% per year, the power of compounding growth can mathematically grow your contributions into 10,000 times the weekly amount you can set aside.

So, $100 per week could grow to about $1 million in 30 years.

But here’s the kicker—cutting just 5 years from your investment timeline slashes your potential growth by 40%. So you must start as early as possible.

The amount you invest with each paycheck is less important than the amount of time you invest for.

To visualize how Time is most powerful ally in wealth creation, plug your numbers in this Growth Calculator and see for yourself.

Step 2: Get the Employer Match to your Contributions!

Most companies would match your own contributions into the employer retirement plan (often up to 5% of your salary)—but only if you contribute first. That match is actually part of your compensation, but your employer gets to keep it if you don’t contribute.

So always set your initial contribution at least where it would get you the full employer match! If you don’t get the employer match, you’re voluntarily taking a pay cut!

Step 3: Pay Yourself First

Having enough money to live on for 30 years means investing at least 15% of your income during your working years. So before spending anything, you absolutely must invest a percentage of your paycheck first. And employer retirement plans make this very easy because your retirement contributions are taken out from your paycheck before they can even hit your bank account. This automated investment for retirement makes it harder to spend it or use it for anything else other than long-term compounded growth for your retirement. And that’s a good thing!

But you have to commit to invest a percentage of your income—with each and every paycheck—like clockwork! Start by contributing whatever amount you need to in order to get your employer’s full match, and then gradually raise it every year until you’re contributing at least 15% of your gross income (including the employer match).

The best part? Once you’ve reached the 15% target investment rate, you can spend the rest of your paycheck guilt-free! Well—almost… so long as you’ve played all your other cards right, too! 😉

Step 4: To Roth or Not to Roth?

Tax strategy is the real meat of all retirement accounts. After all, that's why they are all called "tax-advantaged" investments. So a big part of your winning strategy is to maximize those tax benefits.

Let's do the math! Each year, the IRS sets an annual maximum you’re allowed to contribute into your employer retirement plan. For 2026, the IRS lets you contribute up to $24,500 per year if you’re under 50 (and more if you’re 50+), regardless of your income.

And one more important nuance: Roth contributions inside many employer plans (like a Roth 401(k) or Roth 403(b)) aren’t restricted by Roth IRA income limits—if your plan offers the Roth option, you can typically use it regardless of income.

If you are able to contribute the maximum allowed every year, your total retirement balance would be around $3 million after 30 years, assuming an average annual return of 8% over that time.

But what about the taxes on all that growth? The answer to that question actually depends on the type of account flavor you initially picked for your investments: Traditional or Roth account.

· A Roth account is ideal if you’re younger or early in your career, are in a low tax bracket (22% or lower), and expect your future tax brackets to be higher than they are now—including in retirement.
· Traditional (tax-deferred) retirement accounts are best-suited if you’re currently in a high tax bracket or at the peak of your earnings, so you would expect to be in a lower tax rate in retirement when you’re no longer working. But you should watch out for traps discussed below.
· If you’re on the fence—most people would do best by investing in both because nobody can predict what their future tax rates will be, especially decades from now. This would give you important tax diversification.

Step 5: Invest Consistently and Delay Withdrawals

Employer plans are designed to make it easy to put money in—straight from your paycheck—but will penalize you if you pulled money out before you’re 59½. You would not only lose out on the tax benefits, but in most cases would also have to pay an extra 10% penalty on the amount you withdraw early.

And that’s by design! Or else too many would be tempted to use their retirement accounts as a primary piggy bank for other expenses rather than for their primary purpose: to save enough to live with no income for 20 or 30 years—or maybe longer.

This is why your Smart Card™ will treat your retirement accounts as illiquid assets until you reach the age 59½. And it’s also why having sufficient liquid assets—like cash reserves and brokerage investments that you can tap into at any time—is so essential.

Step 6: Consider Target Date Funds

Your employer will offer many investment choices—which can feel overwhelming. But almost everyone can simplify things by choosing Target Date Funds for their contributions.

These funds start aggressive when you're younger, then automatically adjust to more conservative investments as you near the target retirement date. It’s the closest thing to a set-it-and-forget-it investment strategy, allowing high growth in early years while gradually reducing risk in later years.

You can recognize the target date funds quite easily by their names: they all have the target year in the name of the investment: such as 2050, 2055, 2060, and so on.

The target date on the investment does not mean that you have to retire then. It only means that your investments will become more and more conservative the closer they get to that date. And always remember that this also means targeting lower future growth, too!

For example, a target date fund for 2065 will target much higher growth right now—and thus bring more investment risk—than a fund with a target date of 2040.

Just remember—target date funds cannot eliminate investment risk, so you need to balance it with smart decisions across your entire financial plan—and by playing all your other cards right too.

Step 7: Roll Over Plans When Changing Employers

Your employer would typically allow you to keep your investments with them when you leave your job and will continue to manage them for you if you just left them there. But that may come with high fees. And if your employer goes out of business, you may have to jump through a lot of red tape and knuckle-biting hoops to get your funds transferred into your name.

So if you don’t have an IRA account, you should open one and roll them in one place over every time you jump ship. This could not only help you save on fees, but would make it so much easier to have your investments in a single account.

Final Thought: Play This Card Right

Your retirement plan is one of the most powerful financial tools you have—but it only works if you take full advantage of it.

Start early, get that employer match, invest consistently, and stay smart about taxes and investment risk.

And remember—retirement isn’t just about stopping work. It’s about starting something new, with the financial security that lets you do what you love.

Frequently Asked Questions

Take your finances to the next level!

Play Your Cards Right™

Join Tobi